Initiative 42: Are You Fed Up with being Manipulated Yet?

Initiative 42 is the result of nearly 200,000 Mississippians signing petitions to have an initiative placed on the November ballot to amend the state Constitution.   If passed, this citizen led initiative will hold the Mississippi Legislature accountable for keeping its promise to fully fund public schools, which the Legislature has fulfilled only twice in the past 18 years. That should be simple enough; however, Governor Phil Bryant, Lieutenant Governor Tate Reeves, and Speaker of the House Phillip Gunn have used their power and position to help confuse the public about the Initiative. Why? Such action is contrary to statements the Governor has made in the past regarding the public’s role in education. For example, in a December 2, 2014 article by The Associated Press, Governor Bryant said the “public” is in charge of education. But, if he truly believes the public is in charge of education, why is he campaigning against the charge of close to 200,000 Mississippians?   He has also advocated for parental choice in education. However, if he is pro parent choice, why does he oppose Initiative 42, which is supported by parents who have made a “choice” to stand up for public school funding? If he truly believes in parent choice and believes the public is in charge of education, why hasn’t he stepped aside and let the public decide the issue without his political interference?

The reason is simple! In maybe the truest statement by the Republican leadership since the Initiative 42 debate began, Lieutenant Governor Tate Reeves in an October 22 article by Valerie Wells, published in the Hattiesburg American, stated Initiative 42 is a struggle for power rather than funding. “It’s not about funding,” Reeves said. “It’s about power.” Although Republicans would like for the public to believe Initiative 42 is about Democrats versus Republicans, black versus white, or a power hungry chancery court judge in Hinds County usurping the sovereignty of the state, those are simply smokescreens! The truth is as Reeves stated, “It’s about power.” For the political leadership in Jackson, this issue is about the power and control of the people to hold the state Legislature accountable to the law versus the power and control of the state Legislature to do as it pleases with no boundaries or accountability.

Although fear of losing “power and control” may be at the heart of the Republican opposition to Initiative 42, we must be careful their struggle to maintain power does not overshadow the original purpose of the grassroots initiative led by the people of Mississippi. Power was the furthest thing from the minds of the citizens who signed the petitions to place Initiative 42 on the ballot. Their intent was to help struggling teachers reach all children – poor, middle class, rich, black, and white; their intent was to keep public education alive. Unfortunately, at times, that intent seems to have been lost beneath the clouds of political smoke swirling around such issues as top heavy school districts and school consolidation. We need to save those discussions for another day. Besides, no one in Jackson has any intentions of tackling those political time bombs in the near future; such issues are simply there to confuse and divide the public.

In an era where a good education is a prerequisite for success in life, the idea anyone would not support funding education is mind boggling. At a time when Mississippi needs everyone working together to pull our state from the clutches of poverty by creating an educated work force with more options than unemployment or a minimum wage existence, it is unbelievable we have elected officials who refuse to make education a priority. In a state as untrusting of government as Mississippi, it is beyond belief the citizens would tolerate a governor and state legislators who believe they are above the law. At a time when the public has the opportunity to remind the state Legislature that they are not only in charge of public education as Governor Bryant says, but they are in charge of their elected representatives in Jackson as well, it is unthinkable politicians might actually get their way and not be held accountable to the law.

As a state, we should be ashamed for having this debate. It is disgraceful some would put politics above the needs of our children. It is appalling some people look for excuses not to support education rather than look for reasons to support it. It is disappointing Mississippi citizens needed to sign petitions to put an initiative on the ballot to force elected officials to do their jobs and follow the law. And, it is reprehensible public officials would use or condone the use of half-truths, fabrications, and scare tactics to misguide the public. It is unfortunate, but the current struggle for power and education funding resembles a throwback to the Mississippi of the 1950’s and 1960’s rather than the new enlightened Mississippi we have struggled to become since those dark days.

In spite of this apparent throwback, we are a more enlightened people! We have made tremendous strides since the 50’s and 60’s, but as the Initiative 42 issue has shown, we still have a long way to go in regard to our attitudes toward education, race, and our future. Too much of our past biases still lurk in who we are as a state. Hopefully, additional time will further eradicate those prejudices from us – at least from our children. Nevertheless, I believe for the most part Mississippians are good people who strive to do what is right. We are proud people often recognized as the most benevolent state in the nation! Mississippians are quick to come to the aid of others, whether they are in this country or countries halfway around the world. Mississippians have always generously given to those in need. It so happens, our children are the ones in need this time. It is time we looked in our own backyard and shared our benevolence with our own family. It is time we stood by our children and their teachers; there is no better place to share your generosity and compassion than with those who live in your backyard.

I pray the people of Mississippi will stand up for Initiative 42 and not be led astray by professional politicians with political agendas that often exclude what is best for our state. With Initiative 42, public school education has a chance to be funded as required by law; without it, the chances are slim and none. If you don’t want to vote for Initiative 42, that is your right, but if that is your choice, why not at least do the next best thing and vote those politicians committed to sabotaging public education out of office? Citizens concerned for education and the future of Mississippi need to send a message one way or the other that we are fed up with political manipulation not only at the federal level but at the state level as well.


©Jack Linton, PhD. October 29, 2015

2 thoughts on “Initiative 42: Are You Fed Up with being Manipulated Yet?

  1. Ken Brannan

    I love education, and have quite a bit of it. I love educators and the educational system in this state. My siblings and I received ‘adequate’ and ‘reasonable’ educations, with a much lower ‘cost per student’ ratio than anything that is available now. My children received a very good education in Petal schools, at a much lower ‘cost per student’ level than is accomplished in many other areas.
    Perhaps the MAEP concept was not a good idea. Perhaps having good representatives and leaders in places of responsibility, as we have now, is a much better idea. Even a PEER review from 2002 seems to cast some doubt on the whole idea of MAEP, borrowing MAEP (subjective) words like ‘adequate’ and ‘reasonable’ and even stating as follows: “The formula does not account for school district efficiency, a factor that could, over the long term, affect funding levels. The formula does not allow for unusual growth or loss in districts’ enrollments. Also, neither state law nor departmental regulations require an accountability mechanism to ensure that at-risk funds added to district allocations are actually targeted for the at-risk student population.”
    Someone stated recently that there are always enough funds to fully fund MAEP. I wondered if that person knew of some hidden stash of cash under a big rock. It could be that we just need to do the best we can with the funds that are available for all the needs of the State Of Mississippi. – re-posted from a few days ago – Ken Brannan


    1. jlinton77 Post author

      I am pleased to hear your children received a great education in the Petal School District. For a school district such as Petal, that is to be expected; however, not every district is as fortunate as Petal in local funding, teacher quality, and community support. It takes all three to have a successful school district. The district has the facilities, material resources, community support and local funding to compete for the best teachers in the state, and that makes a difference in the classroom. Of course, the residents of Petal pay some of the highest school taxes you will find anywhere in the state, but for their children it pays off. However, even Petal has been shortchanged and forced to cut budgets year after to year to make ends meet due to under-funding of the MAEP formula. If not for local revenue sources helping supplement MAEP funding, Petal would most likely be in the same sad shape as so many other school districts. For example, Petal teachers are paid a higher local supplement than they would receive in many other school districts (the local teacher supplement for some schools can run as little as $1.00 per year). Some schools in poorer parts of the state have very little local funding to add to their underfunded MAEP allotment, so it is hard for them to compete for the better teachers. Please, do not get me wrong, I am not saying there are not good teachers in those districts, but they face many obstacles that Petal, Madison, or Lamar County teachers do not face. The bottom line is that all Mississippi schools need the MAEP funding they were promised. As for a hidden stash, you might want to address that with Governor Bryant, Lieutenant Governor Reeves, and Speaker of the House Gunn since all three of them advocate phasing out state income taxes that account for as much as 40% of total state revenues. Apparently, they know of a stash under a big rock somewhere. If they do, it’s time they rolled it out.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s