The Reality of School Cuts if Initiative 42 Fails

People opposed to Initiative 42 like to speculate on the cuts other Mississippi state agencies may face if the Initiative passes, but they fail to see the cuts public schools live with everyday; cuts that are not speculative.  Cuts in public school are a reality!  K – 12 public schools have been steadily cutting their budgets for years! It is not uncommon for school districts in Mississippi to cut their budgets by as much as 15% to open the school doors to start the school year, cut the budget again at Christmas by another 10%, and then cut 5% in the spring to keep the schoolhouse doors open until May. While cuts to other state agencies are at this point pure speculation at best, there is nothing speculative about the present reality of cuts in public schools and the forthcoming cuts that will result if Initiative 42 does not pass. Many of our state schools are to the point they cannot continue to make cuts and keep the schoolhouse doors open!

The problem is that too many in the public are not aware of the financial struggles their community schools have been facing. Why should they be? School district superintendents, school boards, and the faculty and staff have always “sucked it up” and moved forward in the best interests of the children despite the cuts. The problem is they have “sucked it up” until the well is almost sucked dry. Unfortunately, as long as the school buses keep rolling, the lights keep flickering on in classrooms, and the football team and the band plays on Friday nights, the public will continue to believe all is well and good in “public school land.” However, financially, all is not good in “public school land!” Let’s not kid ourselves, it’s time Mississippians consider the magnitude of public school cuts and what those cuts will mean not only to their children but to their communities as well if Initiative 42 fails to pass.

As I have said elsewhere, with or without Initiative 42, Mississippi will continue to have school – at least for the foreseeable future. Whatever cuts happen in the public schools, few in the public will notice until those cuts begin to hit home. The public will not notice until family members who work in schools as assistant teachers, custodians, maintenance workers, clerical staff, and even teachers are sent home without a job because there is little or no money to pay them. The public will not notice until the local schoolhouse doors are closed and their children are bused across counties thirty or forty miles to the nearest school still open. And, the public will not notice there is a serious financial problem in public schools until the football team and the band stops playing on Friday night!

Unfortunately, most people in the public do not believe these things are possible. They take public schools and the education it provides their children, the jobs it provides people in their community, and the sense of pride it instills in their community for granted. They shouldn’t!  If the public does not make public school education a priority by passing Initiative 42, these things are very much in jeopardy.  Unless, the public demands their public schools become a priority in Jackson, they should expect major cuts in their community schools. Folks, this “ain’t no” scare tactic! If you think it is, take a serious look at the following decisions regarding your community schools that will need to be made if adequate funding for public schools is not addressed soon. This list is not speculation of the cuts that will need to be considered! These are cuts local school boards will have to consider unless there is adequate funding for education in their school districts.

Cuts the public can expect to see if community public schools are not properly funded:

  1. Non-certified personnel cuts: Although this list does not necessarily represent cuts in priority order, the first cuts usually made in a school district are in the area of non-certified personnel (non-teaching positions). Therefore, if there are assistant teachers in schools, they will probably be the first to be sent home without a job. Next in line to lose their jobs due to cuts will be cafeteria workers, custodians, clerical staff, and maintenance personnel, and any other non-certified positions;
  2. School Counselors cut: Although school counselors are already in short supply in most schools, without proper funding, you can expect to see school counselor positions eliminated in all but the wealthiest school districts;
  3. School Nurses cut: School nurses may be cut to one per school district, or none at all;
  4. School Security cut: In an era when school safety and security are a major concern, school security officers may have to be cut to one per school district, or cut completely;
  5. Program cuts: Districts will be forced to look very closely at course/subject offerings. Tough choices will have to be made about such courses/programs as foreign languages, visual arts, performing arts, choir, physical education, driver education, technology, vocational programs, and tutoring programs to determine which programs, if any, survive;
  6. Certified personnel cuts:  Many districts will have to cut the number of teachers in their districts, which will result in more students in each classroom as well as reduced course/subject offerings;
  7. Extracurricular activities cut: Extracurricular activities such as band, show choir, and sports (football, basketball, baseball, softball, volleyball, etc.) will have to be severely cut back or eliminated altogether. For example, school districts could save money by eliminating the purchase and upkeep of athletic and band uniforms and equipment. Money could be saved by cutting athletic trainers, and cutting back or eliminating band directors, football coaches, etc. Savings could be realized by parking athletic, band, and cheerleader buses. Many schools across the state will be forced to take hard looks at the financial feasibility of keeping extracurricular activities in their community schools;
  8. School Schedules shortened:  The length of the school day as well as cutting schools to a four day week would have to be considered. By moving to a four day school week, school districts theoretically could save as much as 20% of their overhead costs such as utilities, transportation, food services, and salaries for both certified and non-certified personnel. Of course, such a move might also impact parents financially since they would need to pay for daycare services for younger children who would normally be in school;
  9. Facility decisions/cuts: There will be little new construction, and even basic maintenance needs will have to be cut to the bare minimum. This has already happened in many school districts, and will only get worse without adequate funding;
  10. Transportation cuts: (1) If extracurricular activities survive the cuts, the number of games and contests will need to be drastically reduced, thereby saving on transportation costs; (2) Without funding for transportation upgrades (new buses) and maintenance, double routing school buses packed to capacity will become the norm as buses are taken out of service without money to repair or replace them; and (3) To save on transportation costs, school field trips at all grade levels will need to be eliminated.

I am sure there are other school district cuts I am leaving out, but the point is, it is speculation at best to say state agencies will be cut 7.8% if Initiative 42 passes, but it is NOT speculation to say that school districts will have to make cuts, even dramatic cuts, if Initiative 42 does not pass – the cuts are already happening! Schools are expensive, but the impact of not adequately funding community schools will impact not only the education of our children, but the economy of our communities (loss of wages from shortened work schedules and layoffs), and community pride as well. The only protection against public school cuts and the devastation such cuts cause our children and our communities is to VOTE for INITIATIVE 42!

JL

©Jack Linton, PhD November 2, 2015

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “The Reality of School Cuts if Initiative 42 Fails

  1. ColRebSez

    The Democrats never fully funded MAEP when they controlled the legislature and there was never all this talk about massive cutbacks. The Republican legislature has increased appropriations by record amounts every year, even in the midst of the worst worldwide financial crisis since the Great Depression.

    If you look at the performance of Mississippi school districts, you will find that some that spend the most per student are among the worst in the state while others that spend the least are among the best. Throwing money at this problem isn’t going to solve it, and letting a Hinds County judge have control of our state’s schools certainly won’t help.

    Like

    Reply
    1. jlinton77 Post author

      Lack of adequately funding education is not a Democrat or a Republican issue, it is an issue with both parties. Mississippi under Democrats or Rebulicans has always been reluctant to fund education. I agree the last two years the Republicans have spent more on education, but they have still underfunded their commitment to education by 200 million dollars or more each of those years. Public education has been shortchanged 1.7 billion dollars since 2009, so I am not sure where you are getting the idea that educators are looking for extra money. If you want to talk about throwing money at lost causes, the Mississippi Legislature has thrown money that was committed to public education at corporations such as Nissan for jobs that go to employees from out of state to the tune of 1.3 billion dollars since 2009. If the Legislature had followed the law and spent that money on education as they were obligated by law to do, there would not be an issue with education spending today. It is a shame when the citizens have to draw up a Constitutionsl amendment to get elected officials to do their jobs. Besides, we don’t know for sure if throwing more money at education will work or not since we have never tried it!

      Like

      Reply
      1. ColRebSez

        The legislature is not “obligated by law” to fully fund MAEP. No legislature can bind any future legislature to appropriate money. The courts have ruled as much.

        Throwing money at education has been tried, and it was a complete and total failure, resulting in lower test scores and higher drop-out rates. Just Google “Kansas City” and throwing money at education and you will see how a judge forced Missouri to piss away $2 billion for nothing.

        I do think the people of Mississippi are eager to talk about our educational system, but it involves more than money.

        Like

      2. jlinton77 Post author

        You may not always get the results you expect or want, but I don’t think spending money on education is pissing it away regardless of the results. We as a state and nation waste far more than 2 billion on enterprises with nowhere near the benefits received from education. However, I hope you are right about people in Mississippi being eager to talk about education, and I certainly hope those talks involve more than just money. As an educator for 37 years, I saw things that can be improved, but I never saw the waste you seem to be convinced exists across the state. Although I remain convinced our schools need the money that was promised them, I agree completely that if there is waste, it needs to be addressed and corrected. Most educators I know would gladly address waste if they saw it. What we need is some of these people who keep screaming about waste to get down to specifics and point out what they believe to be waste, so it can be fixed. I agree we need to fix problems, but we do not need to condemn the whole education system when those problems, many of which are beyond the teachers’ control, are slow to be fixed. The majority of the problems teachers face that need the most fixing begin at home, and you are right, no amount of money can fix that problem.

        Like

  2. Pingback: Mississippi Education Blog | Linton: The Reality of School Cuts if Initiative 42 Fails

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s